Skip to content

0004: Newer evidence replaces older, and older never replaces newer

Status: Accepted

Context

ingest is run again as evidence arrives, and attestation directories are not ordered: a run can read last month's attestation after this week's.

Decision

A server's verdict comes from its newest attestation, ordered by the attestation's ranAt. An attestation at least as new as the stored one replaces it; an older one is recorded but does not replace the verdict. Ingesting the same evidence twice changes nothing.

Consequences

  • The order in which files are ingested does not change the answer.
  • A fixed server stops passing its risk to agents on the next ingest of an attestation that no longer fails the check.
  • TestAttestationsBecomeServersAndIngestingTwiceChangesNothing and TestCriticalFindingsAreInheritedAndFixingThemRemovesTheRisk enforce both properties.